Whether you want to try a new shoe style from the famous Merrell Moab collection or need a pair for hiking on rainy days, you can’t go wrong with the Merrell Moab Ventilator and Waterproof.
Though we accept the fact that most of the Merrell Moab versions look quite alike, you should make it clear they are not, their intended purpose and materials make each product unique.
With that being said, this comparison between the Merrell Moab Ventilator and Merrell Moab Waterproof will give you all the information you need to know before getting a pair for yourself. So, Let’s begin
Similarities and Differences between Merrell Moab Ventilator And Waterproof:
| Features | Merrell Moab Ventilator | Merrell Moab Waterproof |
|---|---|---|
| Launched in | 2017-2020 | 2019-2022 |
| Stability | Stable | Moderately stable |
| Flexibility | Flexible | Less Flexible |
| Sizing | 6.5-15 for Men5-11.5 for Women | 7-15 for Men5-13 for Women |
| Weight | 14 oz. per shoe | 16 oz. per shoe |
| Cushion | Air cushioning | Heavy cushioning |
| Outsole | TCF5+ | TCF5+ |
| Insole | Kinetic Fit | Kinetic Fit |
| Midsole | EVA Foam with Nylon Shank | EVA Foam with Nylon Shank |
| Upper | Pig suede/ Leather/ Mesh | Pig suede/ Leather/ Mesh and waterproof membrane |
| Retail Price | $110-$120 | $135-$165 |
Merrell Moab Ventilator VS Waterproof: Good, Bad, and the Worst:
Now we will compare these two Merrel Moab models in different segments to evaluate who outperforms the other.
1) Comfort:
There is a lot of similarity in the construction of the Merrell Moab Ventilator and Waterproof, thus these two shoe styles should provide the almost same level of comfort.
However, the best thing about these models is you will not suffer from the unbearable breaking-in period as the upper and tongue are substantially cushioned with closed-cell foam, creating a resilient layer between your feet and the ground.
The nylon arch shank in these models protects the foot from shock and it is not as stiff and uncomfortable as the metal plates used in ordinary hiking boots and trail runners.
Moreover, the thicker heel area of these has an air pocket that helps cushion and reduce fatigue when hiking on rocky or broken ground. It also helps angle the foot when climbing steeper, which keeps the ankle from bending as you go up.
The main difference I noted in terms of comfort is, despite the top of the Moab Ventilator being very thick and padded, still the rib-like vents that ran down the boot provided enough airflow to make your feet dry and cool. Whereas, you might feel sweat and discomfort in the Merrell Moab Waterproof boots specifically in hot weather due to the use of additional material and layers.
In addition, the 2-oz weight reduction in the Moab Ventilator is noteworthy; as a result, they feel lighter, which can be especially beneficial when worn for extended periods.
2) Popularity:
The Merrell Moab Ventilator and Moab Waterproof are extremely popular among hikers, adventurers, trail goers, nature enthusiasts, and athletes. These models are even been highlighted in publications such as HYPEBEAST, Forbes, and Travel + Leisure.
Also, Check Out our Comparison B/W Moab 2 and Moab 3
3) Running:
The Merrell Moab Ventilator and Waterproof are quite a bit heavier than your standard running shoes.
They’re built to last with a sturdy Vibram sole and rugged construction overall. Neither of these designs is optimal for running because you need greater flexibility to move your foot naturally across different surfaces.
Furthermore, if you want to run in them, it is to be expected that you will experience discomfort in your arches or lower back after a few minutes due to the rigidity of the sole.
4) Walking:
The Merrell Moab Ventilator and Waterproof is meant to use on uneven terrains like mud, grass, soil, rocks, and roots, they don’t perform well in city areas like pavement or concrete. If you reside in a colder climate, however, these boots will keep your feet warmer and more comfy to walk than any other footwear.
Still, if you spend a great deal of time indoors walking while wearing Moab Waterproof boots, you may feel too hot, due to insulation materials even in lower temperatures.
5) Flat Feet:
The soles of these Merrell models have better cushioning and stability for every foot type. Each with an 11 mm heel-to-toe drop, will give more arch support than other shoe styles so for people with flat feet or a minimal arch the “Merrell Moab Ventilator and Waterproof” are the preferable options.
6) Design:
Merrell designed its Ventilator and Waterproof models with a Kinetic Fit blended EVA contoured footbed that contributes to the ease of wear and feels durable enough to withstand multiple seasons of hiking without replacement.
The strong construction of Merrell Moab Waterproof provides adequate protection from mild snow and occasional rain, up to around the bottom of your ankle depth.
While this model is treated with a durable water repellent to keep water at a distance, you will find that large pores of mesh quickly soaked up creek water and dew from wet grass. However, the flaw is even after being exposed to some sunlight while hiking, the upper material (particularly the leather) was slow to dry after being wet.
Therefore, the brand introduced a built-in waterproofing system in new versions of this model rather than Gore-Tex to make it more efficient in watery conditions.
All in all, The Moab Waterproof is very versatile since it can be used in both dry and wet climates and lasts a long time.
On the other hand, if you’re looking for affordable and capable summer hiking footwear, you can consider the Merrell Moab Ventilator, which has a reputation for being lightweight and durable. So, these shoes are more than suitable for withstanding a lot of trail abuse and keep out dirt, rocks, and other weather elements.
You will feel like you’re floating through the air due to the mesh lining and breezy feel of this model. Also, their cushioned midsole will combat shock and offer stability to the foot all working together for protection of your feet.
In short, Merrell Moab Ventilator is great for extra breathability during any activity more specifically in hot climates, whether you’re hiking, working out, walking, or just going about your day-to-day life.
What do customers think?
So many hikers admire the Merrell Moab Waterproof and Ventilator’s custom fit and comfort.
Reviewers note that there is an apparent distinction between the supports of the Merrell Moab waterproof compared to other models of the same series.
So many explorers signify the Moab Waterproof’s fantastic all-terrain traction and the effectiveness of the outsole in preventing slippage on both roads and natural surfaces.
Hikers even claim that their feet get hot sometimes, which is normal for any waterproof shoe, but they don’t think it’s a deal breaker.
Some buyers have said that these boots feel a little tight in the toe box or are just too small overall and a few people don’t like the back padding because it can get uncomfortable after a while.
Conversely, the Merrell Moab Ventilator receives high praise for its exceptional durability and gripping outsole. Many people say that this Merrell product can get them through even sharp elements, without getting damaged.
Trail goers also love how the Moab Ventilator supports them, especially around the arch.
A lot of people are happy that their feet get a lot of breeze in hot climates while climbing or that they last long enough.
However, in the list of many admirable characteristics, there are a few flaws, most notably heel slippage. Hikers were also dissatisfied with its lack of cushioning, restrictive fit, and unimpressive waterproofing.
Some of them mentioned that they had to stop and re-lace these boots a few times while hiking or walking, which can be annoying.
Conclusion: What Should You Buy?
Your final decision about the Merrell Moab Ventilator VS Waterproof will be depending upon the weather conditions and area you are going for a hike.
Merrell Moab Ventilator is best suited for warm weather because there is good airflow in these and they are light in weight but the drawback of this style is the lack of water resistance. However, if you’re looking for a hiking shoe that can often be worn around town the Merrell Moab Ventilator is the way to go.
On the other hand, if you choose the Merrell Moab Waterproof, you should know that your feet are likely to get sweaty in the middle of summer or indoors.
In my point of view, the Merrell Moab Waterproof is your best bet if you are planning to wear it in wet conditions and don’t mind the reduced airflow & additional dollars.